Every year when Easter comes around, I try to build baskets that feel fun and thoughtful without filling them with random plastic toys or too much candy.
You know the kind — the baskets that look exciting for five minutes and then everything ends up forgotten in the bottom of a toy bin.
But something funny happened when I attended the New York Toy Fair this year.
Within the first few aisles I caught myself thinking:
“Wait… this would actually make a really great Easter basket stuffer.”
And then it kept happening.
Walking Toy Fair gives you a completely different perspective than scrolling through toys online. You see which products people stop for, which ones kids immediately reach for, and which toys make parents smile the second they recognize them.
If you’re curious about the bigger toy trends I spotted this year, I also share more about what’s trending at New York Toy Fair.
By the end of the day I had mentally built an entire Easter basket just from the things I discovered walking the show floor.
So if you’re looking for the best Easter basket stuffers for kids, these are some of the Toy Fair finds that instantly made my list.
Why Toy Fair Is the Best Place to Discover Trending Toys
Toy Fair is where brands launch what will be trending months before it hits big retailers.
Walking the floor is honestly one of my favorite parts of being a blogger because you get a sneak peek into what kids are gravitating toward right now.
You can immediately tell which toys have that “wait… this is cool” reaction.
Some booths were quiet.
Others had kids and adults squeezing fidget toys, laughing at nostalgic characters, and influencers filming reels nonstop.
Those are the toys that make it onto my radar.
And many of them happen to be perfect Easter basket stuffers for kids because they’re:
- Small enough for baskets
- Affordable
- Fun to open
- Interactive
- Non-candy alternatives
Which is exactly what so many parents are searching for now.
Character Toys That Make Great Easter Basket Stuffers
One thing I noticed while exploring Toy Fair is that recognizable characters still create the biggest reactions.
Since the show is really about seeing what toys will be hitting the market this season, it’s interesting to watch which displays people gravitate toward naturally.
As I walked through the aisles I kept seeing the same thing happen.
Kids would spot a character they recognized across a booth display.
Parents would smile.
And suddenly everyone wanted to pick one up.
Character toys are always a hit with kids, especially when they already love the characters from experiences like our visit to CAMP in New York City.
Hello Kitty Plush Danglers
One of the cutest character finds I spotted was these Hello Kitty Plush Danglers.
Sanrio characters are having a huge moment again right now, and these mini plush danglers combine nostalgia with something kids love — collectibles.
Instead of a traditional plush toy, each one clips onto backpacks, lunch bags, or pencil cases.
That makes them perfect Easter basket stuffers for kids because they’re small, recognizable, and something kids can actually use every day.
They’re also a fun option if you’re trying to build a basket with non-candy Easter gifts.
Subscribe to For The Love To!
Get updates on the latest posts and more from For The Love To straight to your inbox.
By submitting your information, you’re giving us permission to email you. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Surprise & Collectible Easter Basket Stuffers Kids Love
Small collectible toys are always exciting because kids never know exactly what they’re going to get.
That little surprise moment makes them perfect Easter basket fillers.
Care Bears Caring Cuties Blind Box Plush
Another colorful discovery I spotted while walking the floor at the New York Toy Fair was the Care Bears Caring Cuties blind box plush from Basic Fun!.
If you grew up loving Care Bears, this one brings a fun mix of nostalgia and collectible surprise. Each Caring Cutie comes in a blind box, so kids won’t know which character they’re getting until they open it.
Each figure features a vinyl face with a soft plush body and a clip that can attach to backpacks, water bottles, or bags.
Because they’re small, colorful, and collectible, they make a really fun Easter basket stuffer for kids.
Care Bears Pocket Stars Blind Pack
Another Toy Fair find that fits perfectly into an Easter basket is the Care Bears Pocket Stars Blind Pack from PMI Kids’ World.
These collectible mini figures come in blind boxes, which means kids don’t know which character they’ll get until they open it.
That little moment of surprise is exactly why blind box toys are so fun.
They’re small, collectible, and exciting to open — everything you want in an Easter basket stuffer for kids.
Cute Plush Easter Basket Stuffers
Sometimes the best Easter basket items are simply soft, adorable plush toys.
One of the booths that completely caught my attention this year featured the Spudsters collection from Aurora World.
Highland Cow Plush – Aurora Spudsters Collection
This plush might actually be my favorite Toy Fair discovery.
Aurora’s Spudsters plush collection is designed with a rounded, potato-inspired shape that makes the plush toys extra soft and squishy.
The Highland Cow plush instantly stood out with its fluffy horns, warm brown fur, and sweet expression.
Farm-themed plush toys like this make wonderful Easter basket stuffers for toddlers and young kids, especially because they’re soft, comforting, and easy to recognize.
It’s the kind of plush that quickly becomes a bedtime favorite.
Educational Easter Basket Stuffers Kids Can Build With
Not every Easter basket toy has to be just for fun.
Some of the toys I spotted at Toy Fair also add a little creativity and learning into the mix.
MAGNA-TILES microMAGS Spring Garden Travel Set
Another toy that immediately caught my attention while exploring the show floor was the microMAGS Spring Garden travel set from MAGNA-TILES.
This compact travel tin includes 24 micro magnetic tiles, which are smaller versions of the classic MAGNA-TILES pieces kids love building with.
The spring garden theme — complete with colorful tiles and a tiny bunny figure — makes it especially cute for Easter.
Because the pieces store inside a slim metal tin, it’s also a great travel toy for kids.
Numberblocks Blockzee Balance Activity Set
Another educational toy that stood out to me was the Numberblocks Blockzee Balance Activity Set from hand2mind.
Inspired by the popular learning show Numberblocks, this activity set helps kids explore early math concepts like greater than, less than, and equal to by balancing number cubes on Blockzee’s arms.
It’s a playful way to mix learning with hands-on fun, which makes it a great Easter basket addition for kids who enjoy building and problem solving.
Sensory Toys That Make Great Easter Basket Fillers
Another trend that continues to grow every year at Toy Fair is sensory toys.
Parents love them because they keep little hands busy.
Kids love them because they’re fun to squeeze, stretch, and play with.
And they’re perfect small toys for Easter baskets.
Small toys like these also work great for travel. If you’re planning spring trips with kids, I recently shared my favorite family travel essentials for kids.
Crazy Aaron’s Better Butter Thinking Putty
One sensory toy that immediately caught my attention at Toy Fair was this fun twist on a classic from Crazy Aaron’s.
The Better Butter Thinking Putty has an incredibly smooth, buttery texture that makes it satisfying to stretch and squish.
Unlike traditional putty, it feels softer and easier to play with, which makes it especially fun for younger kids.
Because the container is small and portable, it’s perfect for slipping into an Easter basket or bringing along for travel, quiet play, or car rides.
Sensory toys like this can also encourage creativity and hands-on learning. If you’re exploring fun activities for kids at home, I also share helpful homeschool ideas for first-time homeschool moms.
Kawaii Slime – A Colorful Sensory Easter Basket Surprise
One of the displays that instantly made me stop while walking Toy Fair was this adorable collection of kawaii slime.
Each slime container looked like a tiny dessert shop creation — topped with bows, charms, glitter, and bright pastel colors.
Sensory toys like slime remain one of the most popular non-candy Easter basket ideas for kids because they’re fun, creative, and calming to play with.
Kids can stretch it, swirl it, decorate it, and mix textures.
And because the containers are compact, they fit perfectly into an Easter basket alongside plush toys and collectibles.
NeeDoh Nice Cube Glow
Another sensory toy that kept drawing attention while walking the floor at the New York Toy Fair was the NeeDoh Nice Cube Glow from Schylling Toys.
If you’ve seen the original Nice Cube before, you already know why kids love it — it’s incredibly satisfying to squeeze.
This glow version adds a fun twist with bright colors and the signature squishy texture that slowly returns to shape after you press it.
Because it’s small and portable, it makes a great Easter basket stuffer for kids and a fun sensory toy for travel or quiet play.
How I’m Building Easter Baskets This Year
After walking Toy Fair and seeing what kids reacted to most, I realized something.
Easter baskets don’t need to be huge.
They just need a few thoughtful items that feel exciting.
My simple formula now is:
• One plush toy
• One collectible surprise
• One sensory toy
• One small treat
That combination creates a basket that feels fun without being overwhelming.
What Are Good Non-Candy Easter Basket Ideas?
Many parents now look for non-candy Easter basket stuffers for kids, and there are so many fun options.
Some favorites include:
• plush toys
• collectible blind packs
• sensory toys
• mini character figures
• fidget toys
If you’re looking for more gift ideas for kids and families, I love sharing toy discoveries and fun finds throughout the year.
The Little Surprises That Make Easter Morning Special
One of the things I love most about attending the New York Toy Fair is discovering toys in person.
Scrolling online is one thing.
But seeing which toys make people stop, smile, and reach for them?
That tells you everything.
The best Easter basket stuffers for kids aren’t always the biggest toys.
They’re the ones that spark curiosity.
The ones that make kids reach into their basket and say:
“Wait… this is for me?”
And honestly, those little moments are what make Easter morning so special.
📌 Save This for Later
Thank you for supporting my blog! Please note that this post contains affiliate links, and I may receive payments for clicks, purchases, and/or registrations made through these links. It’s important to mention that ForTheLoveTo.com is a proud participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Your support enables me to continue creating valuable content, and I genuinely appreciate it.
Discover more from For The Love To
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.